How to Deal with Decisions about March Madness in the Workplace
Every Spring a national event captures the attention of millions of employees: the NCAA “March Madness” basketball tournaments.
Individuals who are die-hard basketball fans, those who may follow their local college team when they are doing well, and people who just like to pick teams according to their mascots – all become intrigued and involved in following the games.
Understanding March Madness
While “March Madness” is typically referred to as a singular event, those familiar with the tournaments know that they actually are a series of games and regional tournaments over a three-week period. The process begins with “Selection Sunday” where the 68 teams who get to play in the tournament are announced. Individuals then fill out their game brackets to choose who they think will win individual games and eventually, the championship. There often are informal pools for betting on the winners, and more formal versions fans set up on the Internet. The “win or leave” format takes teams from pre-tournament play-in games, through the “Sweet Sixteen”, “Elite Eight”, the “Final Four” and then the championship game.
The Impact of March Madness on Work
Why is it important for supervisors, managers and employers to understand March Madness? Because for many employees, March Madness becomes an important part of their life, influencing their thought time, emotions, and relationships – both personally and at work. And secondly, because many of the games (especially in the first two weeks) are played during the day on weekdays. This creates some challenges at work.
When a game is being played, it is available to be watched or listened to on television, radio and the computer. So, many employees are distracted from their work while a game important to them (or for some people, any game) is being played. Sometimes, when a local team is playing, seemingly the whole city or vicinity “shuts down” to watch – and the experience can actually become a team building experience among colleagues (including good natured teasing for those rooting for the opponent).
The Dilemmas Raised
This raises the question for managers: how should we handle these situations?
- Do we give people the freedom to watch (essentially, providing “time off” of work)?
- Do we set up a formal process where they can use “personal time” to watch the game?
- If they are salaried employees, do we allow them to manage their time as they wish as long as they fulfill their obligations?
- Do we make no allowances and suggest they record the game to watch later?
- What do we do if we know people are watching “on the sly” at their desks or lingering longer in the break room?
Some Guiding Principles
There are numerous, overlapping issues that need to be considered, including any legal implications regarding unequal treatment of employees, how to serve your clients best, decision-making and communication processes, and staff morale.
Let me make some suggestions that can help avoid creating undesired results:
- Whatever options you are considering, be sure and pass them by your HR manager (or your HR legal consultant) to make sure you are not breaking any laws or creating significant risk for being sued for how you handle the issue.
- Understand that individuals feel valued and appreciated in different ways (words of praise, time and attention, help with projects, and tangible gifts are some.) While watching the NCAA tournament games may not be important to you, to some of your employees it is extremely so. Think of someone who attends all of the games, goes to ‘away’ games, wears the college’s sportswear, and talks a lot about the team. You can really “hit the mark” by making it possible for them to watch the game – and employees often respond with sincere appreciation and a higher sense of loyalty to you.
- Discuss the situation with your management team, sales and customer service representatives and make sure you understand the needs of your clients, approaching deadlines, and how you can be responsive during the games, when needed.
- Consider the Benefits, Costs and Potential Risks. Although there are many options on the continuum, if we simplify the options into: a) giving employees flex time to watch the games, and b) not allowing employees to watch the games during work, the following results can be considered.
Allowing Employees to Watch Not Allowing Employees to Watch
*Will make some people happy *It’s easy. Takes virtually no effort
*Could be a potential team building event *Creates less relational drama
*Improve relationships with your staff *No worries about setting a precedent
*Don’t have to deal with “fairness” issues
*Potentially perceived as unfair *People are going to watch (or
*Hassle of scheduling and logistics follow on their computer) anyway
*Time and effort required to set up *Distraction (many won’t be fully
*Probable complaining from some focused on their work)
*Setting a precedent *Pressure from the media and community
*Setting boundaries (how many games?) *Inconsistency
- COMMUNICATE. COMMUNICATE. What seems like a good idea (and a fairly innocuous way of being nice to your employees) can become a nightmare, leading to hurt feelings and frustration, and even major conflict, unfortunately. Talk with your managers and supervisors. Get input from those you know who are interested in watching the games, and hear from those who have no interest at all. Then be clear who is making the decision, how and by when the decision will be made, and the alternatives available (people love choices). Consider including communicating the principles and factors by which the decision was made.
Final Issues to Consider
There is no right or wrong answer for how best to deal with March Madness in the workplace. And the choice you make may vary according to the specific circumstances this year – your local team is involved, there are too many deadlines to meet, etc.
Essentially, the issue becomes a cost / benefit analysis:
- Are the relational and morale benefits worth the hassle?
- How much complaining might there be from non-interested employees?
- Is it necessary to determine equivalent ways to give others some time off?
Regardless of what you choose, enjoy the tournament!Tags: March Madness
Categories Communication, Managing By Appreciation, Questions, Uncategorized, Workplace Culture