The New Path to Healthy Workplaces: Recognition + Appreciation
Employee recognition programs have been in existence for at least three decades — but they aren’t as effective as they used to be. Despite organizations pouring billions of dollars into rewards initiatives, they still face familiar challenges:
- Decreasing employee engagement.
- Higher staff turnover.
- Moderate (at best) job satisfaction ratings.
- A general dysphoria (if not outright discontentment) about their work lives.
So what’s changed? And, more importantly, what actually works? Let’s talk about it.
What’s Undermining Engagement and Morale?
A number of factors — like a semi-tractor truck without brakes barreling down a hill — are combining to create a greater and greater decline in the health of workplace cultures. If you’re serious about workplace culture improvement, you’ll need to consider these real-world trends:
1. Changes In Culture (at large)
Across society, there is greater distrust and lack of respect for institutions and large organizational systems – including government, healthcare, schools, and religious organizations. Simply put, people are more skeptical—and that includes workplace leadership.
2. Shifts In Employees’ Values
Workers report less focus on financial success and benefits with more emphasis on work/life balance, wanting to impact their community and world, and having a sense of purpose in their daily tasks.
3. Employees’ Expectations Around Work
Employees expect more flexibility, both in schedule and location. Just as importantly, they want their voices heard—regardless of how long they have worked there. That desire for mutual respect and shared values is core to modern employee engagement strategies.
4. The Rise of Remote and Hybrid Teams
With fewer face-to-face interactions, the logistics of connection become more complex. Communicating, onboarding, managing, and appreciating remote employees is now a critical skill—not a side consideration.
5. Isolation in the Digital Workplace
As tech-based communication increases (email, chat, virtual meetings), opportunities for spontaneous personal connection decrease. In many organizations, some coworkers have never met in person. The result? A rise in isolation, disconnection, and loneliness.
Differences Between Recognition and Appreciation
To turn the tide, we need to make a critical distinction—employee recognition vs appreciation:
Recognition Prioritizes Performance
First, we need to understand that recognition and appreciation, at their core, differ. As recognition and reward programs have developed over time, they have naturally focused on rewarding high-performing team members. From a behavioral psychology viewpoint, this makes sense—you call attention to and reward those behaviors you want to continue or increase.
However, when taken to an extreme, recognition systems can leave employees feeling like “production units,” as if their only value is tied to their accomplishments.
Appreciation Sees the Whole Person
Appreciation, on the other hand, goes beyond this performance-based perspective. It values employees for who they are, not just for what they do. We all bring qualities to the workplace that never make it into a performance review—like dependability, a cheerful spirit, creative thinking, or steady encouragement.
Appreciation Moves from Person to Person
Another foundational difference is that recognition is an organizational function – it comes down from the top (from either management or human resources) and is communicated through the organizational chart.
Appreciation, by contrast, is inherently relational. It’s person-to-person. You don’t need a formal title to affirm someone else. From the night custodian to the department head, appreciation is universal and accessible. That’s part of what makes it so powerful.
Appreciation Is the Foundation for a Healthy Workplace Culture
Appreciation in the workplace continues to rise as a critical dynamic for healthy workplaces. As interpersonal connection and face-to-face interaction decrease, we’re seeing a rise in disconnection, loneliness, and even distrust among colleagues.
Without this person-to-person connection, we move closer to an Orwellian world, treating each other as objects and without a basis for trusting relationships. Even the most established recognition and reward companies now admit that person-to-person appreciation is essential for a thriving, emotionally healthy workplace.
From Either/Or to Both/And
A major shift is now occurring in the world of human resources and workplace cultures. Some of the largest multinational corporations are now training employees to show authentic appreciation to their colleagues in addition to their existing recognition programs.
Instead of ignoring the need for personal appreciation (or the more recent attempt to rename organization recognition as appreciation), the lack of impact recognition and reward programs are having on employee morale, staff retention, and employee satisfaction is forcing them to admit a more individualized, personal approach is needed.
We don’t believe reward/recognition programs are bad if they are designed well, implemented consistently, and understood to have the true goal of increasing the frequency of desired behaviors and results by employees’ actions.
Blending Systems with Authenticity
We’re now working with organizations of all sizes to implement a hybrid approach that combines effective recognition programs with practical training on how to show authentic appreciation to each other and connect with each other personally.
If you want lasting results in morale, retention, and team cohesion, you’ll need to invest in human connection—because it’s not just about what your people do.
It’s about who they are. Learn more about it in our book The 5 Languages of Appreciation in the Workplace.
BUILD A HEALTHIER WORKPLACE TODAY
Share this:
Categories 5 Languages of Appreciation in the Workplace, Appreciation, Managing By Appreciation, Recognition, Workplace Culture
